Please use the tabs above to navigate to the individual categories, look at the runners-up and even the complete evaluation measures.

Category 1: Team R. Dunn

R. Dunn and team from Birmingham and Manchester submitted results for 11 of the 14 challenges, and obtained the correct solution ranked first for 8 of them, and one second rank. The team missed the solution in two cases. We received submissions from three external participants.

Category 2: H. Oberacher

H. Oberacher submitted results for only five of the challenges, but in three cases his single suggestion was the correct one. He missed the solution in the two other cases. We received submissions from three external participants.

The detailed evaluation and comparison of the results will be part of the special issue Small Molecule Identification beyond the Crystal Ball - Selected Papers from CASMI appearing in the MDPI journal Metabolites later this year.

---

Category 3

Category 4

Unfortunately we did not receive any external submissions for the categories 3 and 4, and the only results we have are from Emma Schymanski and Markus Meringer using MOLGEN-MS and consensus scoring. We therefore do not declare a winner in these two categories, but provide the data for completeness.

---

We provide all submissions as TAR file, and you can browse them in the CASMI version control.